Pages

▼

Sunday, March 6, 2016

From Our Readers: Rethinking Genre and Reimagining Fear: Robert Eggers The Witch

by Emily Shipley


 (image)

One of my favorite scenes from comedy classic Monty Python and the Holy Grail features a parodical witch trial in Medieval England, complete with a beautiful woman with a prosthetic nose tied around her head and a group of angry villagers who take her to Sir Vladimir, local sage. Asks Vladimir, “How do you know she is a witch?” and one of the villagers shouts out in reply, “She looks like one!” Laughs all around—how stupid can these people be to believe in witches? We’re so much smarter than that. Witchcraft is only a thing only resurrected for mockery or entertainment in so many iconic pop culture media today, from film to television to music. So what, you may ask yourselves, does this have to do with Robert Eggers’ recent indie-turned-mainstream release of The Witch? Is this just another mindless horror film?


The short answer is no: it’s not mindless. The Witch is a scary movie. But it’s not a horror film. Here’s why.


Eggers’ spent approximately four years researching early American life in the Plymouth colonies while he amassed funding for his project. He studied documents of the era, court transcripts, pamphlets on witchcraft, Puritan primers, the Geneva Bible, and anything else he could get his hands on to paint a perfect picture of what it would have been like to be a Calvinist living in the New World in 1630. This much is masterfully obvious. Painstaking attention to detail— from costuming, dialogue, architecture, and animal husbandry—makes this movie feel like we are looking into the past. And no matter how much we may expect it of the genre, Eggers refuses to deliver a horror film superimposed on that past. It lacks the stereotypical tropes we expect of modern horror—although yes, there is a witch, and yes, she looks like one—Eggers does not place her as the film’s central figure. Instead, he allows social and religious history to speak for itself, and creates a world of dread, anxiety, and paranoia; it is a world where forces of the supernatural act against an already isolated, self-destructive family.  


The reality of the Puritanical worldview is the vehicle for the “New England Folktale” (Eggers’ subtitle) to come alive. In 2016, we fear different monsters—and those modern monsters are absent from this movie. Instead, we are asked to suspend disbelief, so to speak, and imagine a world where folk/fairy tale is as real as the sun rising every morning and setting every evening. There is no distinction between myth and everyday “real life.” The question isn’t, “Is this house haunted? It can’t be! I don’t believe in ghosts!” The question is, “I believe in witches and demonic possession, so can I free myself and my family of evil?” And the strictest Puritanical answer to that question is, quite simply, no—“in Adam’s fall, we sinned all,” suckers. Viewers are asked to inhabit a world where no one knows what lies beyond this life because of the conundrum of election and limited grace. Hell, no one knows what lies beyond tomorrow, since characters are at the mercy of their environment. It is a world where communities banish the unorthodox, where families fall apart, and no one is in control of anything, including their own lives, because Providence is the moving force of the universe. Oh, and witches that steal your kids, murder them, possess their bodies, and work in concert with Lucifer personified as a murderous black goat? They’re real too.   


Once the audience accepts these new rules of existence, the movie becomes one of the most unsettling, psychologically challenging pieces of art in recent years. So, cultured readers of Bystander— if you want to watch one of the scariest movies of the last decade, go see The Witch. But, if you want a good old-fashioned horror film, maybe wait around for The Conjuring II.

No comments:

Post a Comment