Pages

▼

Friday, April 15, 2016

My Big Fat Greek Shrug

by Emily Shipley


When I first saw a preview for My Big Fat Greek Wedding II, I turned to Christianna, and without a hint of irony, proclaimed: “This is going to be the best movie of the year.”  I unapologetically loved the first movie because, though I was not Greek, I come from a big, sometimes-too-close family that occasionally forgets boundaries, but always does so out of love.  If any of them are reading this right now: I didn’t mean you, I meant someone else.

It turns out I should have said that this movie would be the greatest with some sarcasm.  But, readers of Bystander, it certainly wasn’t the worst movie of the year.  The following review gives you a couple of reasons to see My Big Fat Greek Wedding II and a couple of reasons not to see what Rotten Tomatoes gave only a 27% positive score.

First, the positives.  Did you like the characters of the original movie?  Good news.  They’re all there and they are still the same.  Did you like the running jokes about Windex?  Those are there too.  Did you enjoy the silliness and stereotypes of Greek culture (that many people could actually relate to if they just have overly-involved families)?  No changes there.  It’s a comfortable, predictable rom-com—mindless entertainment we all need sometimes.

One of the laudable aims of this movie is to demonstrate the complications of different seasons of female life, from adolescence, to middle age, to old age.  It is largely a story about women and their roles in families and culture.  Some traditional women’s roles are complicated, some are rigorously upheld, and domesticity is presented as an adventure for some, while education and other goals might be the adventures for others.  A one-size-fits all prescription for female endeavors (wifehood and motherhood) is challenged, but traditional roles are not subjected to mockery in favor of The Modern Woman™.  In plain English: the movie appeals to female audiences of a variety of ages and perspectives and celebrates all of them.

Now, onto the negatives.  My Big Fat Greek Wedding II has no story.  The plot is sacrificed to standard stereotypes, tropes, and corny comedy while the audience decides if this is a movie about Toula trying to deal with her daughter growing up, her parents who were never officially married because their priest never signed the certificate, or something else entirely.  Of one thing we can be sure, though: LOOK HOW EXASPERATING IT IS TO COME FROM A BIG, GREEK FAMILY. We are hit over the head with the “Greekness” of it all, so that two-thirds of the way through, it’s not funny anymore and we’re just waiting for all the storylines to resolve themselves so we can go home.  It’s just a touch tedious.

Another problem with the movie, from my perspective, was the lack of chemistry between characters, especially between John Corbett (Ian) and Nia Vardalos (Toula).  Awkward pauses, careful execution of lines, and disconnectedness characterizes each of their exchanges—even after they reconcile and Toula remembers how to “be a girlfriend” to her husband and still a mother to her daughter, Paris, who shares a name with the Greek prince of mythological fame.  The believability of their love for each other falters throughout 90-minute film.  It left me wondering if they really can’t stand each other when the cameras aren’t rolling.

So if you’re thinking of seeing My Big Fat Greek Wedding II, consider waiting until it hits the cheap theater in your area, or until you can stream it on Netflix when it inevitably arrives there.  Or see it and like it.  That’s cool too.  But, whatever.  It’s a 2016 chick flick, not a Shakespeare adaptation.
 

No comments:

Post a Comment